From Boston terriers to pugs, flat-faced dogs with short noses are prone to health problems, especially respiratory issues. It’s important to educate yourself about these conditions when adopting a brachycephalic breed or mix.
Many of our today’s most popular dogs include brachycephalic dogs such as pugs, Boston terriers and bulldogs. A brachycephalic dog is one with a “shortened head” featuring a short nose and a flat face. In fact, the word “brachycephaly” stems from the Greek root meaning “short” and “head”, and refers to a skull shape that’s shorter than is typical for its species. While brachycephalic breeds appeal to many people, these dogs and their mixes can experience health problems associated with their anatomy and physiology. If you’re adopting a brachycephalic dog, it’s important to know which breeds are prone to these problems and why, and what you can do to minimize issues in your new friend.
- Boston terrier
- Brussels griffon
- Cane corso
- Cavalier King Charles spaniel
- Chinese shar-pei
- Chihuahua (apple-headed)
- Chow chows
- Dogo Argentina
- Dogue de Bordeaux
- English mastiff
- English toy spaniel
- French bulldog
- Japanese chin
- King Charles spaniel
- Lhasa apso
- Neapolitan mastiff
- Shih tzu
- Tibetan mastiff
- Tibetan spaniel
- Yorkshire terrier
Why are these breeds so popular?
Among the many reasons we find human babies so adorable are their large eyes and brachycephalic noses and faces. So it follows that people would also be attracted to the appearance of brachycephalic dogs. Recent research has shown that people prefer these dogs for their appearance, which is often prioritized over their health. In fact, the bulldog and French bulldog rank fourth and fifth in popularity in the US.
Health concerns in brachycephalic dogs
Veterinary professionals around the world have expressed concerns about the increasing health problems encountered in these breeds. A report from the UK in 2015 reported that upper respiratory disorders were commonly diagnosed in bulldogs, French bulldogs, pugs, border terriers, West Highland white terriers and Yorkshire terriers attending primary care veterinary practices in England. The report stated that the three extreme brachycephalic breed types (bulldog, French bulldog and pug) were relatively short-lived and more predisposed to these disorders than the three other breeds (the moderate-brachycephalic Yorkshire terrier and the non-brachycephalic border terrier and West Highland white terrier).
Meanwhile, research undertaken by Cambridge University’s veterinary medicine group compared the prevalence of brachycephalic obstructive airway syndrome in dogs. They found no prevalence of the disease in a control group of non-brachycephalic dogs, but found it in 40% of bulldogs, 46% of French bulldogs, and 60% of pugs.
These respiratory problems arise from anatomical defects of the shortened upper airway, as well as an elongated soft palate. Brachycephalic dogs are also prone to additional health issues (see below).
1. Symptoms of upper respiratory difficulties include breathing difficulties often associated with overheating, as well as sleep apnea, snoring, snorting and regurgitation. These symptoms progress with age and typically become severe by about 12 months. Some people may consider respiratory issues such as snoring or snorting to be normal for their dogs, and may not seek veterinary intervention until a more severe problem occurs.
2. Treatment includes surgical widening of the nostrils, and the removal of excess tissue from elongated soft palates, and any everted laryngeal saccules. Early treatment intervention usually prevents secondary conditions.
Potential complications during and after surgery, such as hemorrhaging, pain and inflammation, may make some veterinarians hesitant to perform soft palate correction surgery. With the advent of surgical lasers, however, these complications are greatly reduced.
3. Prevention involves limiting symptom aggravation and includes avoiding stress and heat, and maintaining an ideal body weight by not overfeeding. Harnesses should be used instead of collars to avoid pressure on the trachea. As brachycephalic dogs are more likely to die during air travel, they have been banned from flights on many airlines.
If you opt to buy from a breeder, try to find one who selects for more moderate features rather than extremely short or flat faces. Dogs with serious breathing difficulties should not be used as breeding stock, even though many breeders continue to do so; many of these dogs end up at shelters and rescue facilities, so educate yourself about their health problems if you’re adopting. Given the high prevalence of respiratory problems in the most popular brachycephalic dogs, however, removing affected animals from the breeding pool may cause some breeds to become unsustainable. This means out-crossing to non-brachycephalic breeds might become necessary, and would actually be a step in the right direction for the future welfare of these dogs.
Additional health problems associated with brachycephalic dogs
- Eye diseases, including entropion, ectropion and distichiasis (eyelashes rubbing on cornea), protruding eyeballs and poor tear production
- Inability to mate or give birth naturally (requiring Cesarean section)
- Repeated skin infections
- Dental problems from crowding and misalignment
- Gastrointestinal problems
Small and toy brachycephalic dogs
Small short-faced breeds may be among the oldest forms of dog. Ancient remains of these dogs have been carbon-dated as far back as 10,000 years. Recent DNA analysis has confirmed that East Asia is the ancestral home of domestic dogs, and other studies have suggested that the Pekingese and pug are among the oldest breeds.
Many toy brachycephalic dogs were bred to be companions and lap dogs in Tibetan monasteries and Chinese palaces. The resulting breed types became intermingled thanks to trading between nations. The ancestors of the pug, Pekingese, and Japanese chin were all one breed, while the ancestors of the Shih tzu and Lhasa apso were very similar.
- Brussels griffon — developed in the 19th century by the Belgians from the Chinese pug and the King Charles (toy) Spaniel. Often kept in stables to eliminate rodents.
- Cavalier King Charles Spaniel – evolved when breeders of King Charles spaniels (English toy spaniel) took their long-nosed throwbacks and created a slightly larger cousin. Cavaliers have a longer nose and a flat head.
- Chihuahua — has pre-Columbian Mexican ancestry. They apparently descended from the Techichi of Mexico, as far back as 300 BC.
- English toy spaniel (King Charles spaniel) — developed by the Dutch from the pug dogs of China. This dog had a pointed muzzle, but crosses to the Japanese chin and pug in the 18th and 19th centuries resulted in dogs with the short muzzles and round apple heads seen today.
- French bulldog — descended directly from the Molossian dogs of an ancient Greek tribe, and spread via Phoenician traders. In the 1800s, a cross between bulldog ancestors imported from England, and local rat terriers in Paris, led to today’s French bulldog.
- Japanese chin — an ancient breed originating from the “Gobi Desert Kitchen Midden Dog” in China, then brought to Japan.
- Lhasa apso – this ancient breed hails from Tibet, where it was called the “barking lion sentinel dog”, alerting the monks to intruders. They were never sold, only given as gifts.
- Pekingese — native to China, this is one of the most ancient dog breeds, and was treasured by Chinese Emperors. These dogs share a common ancestry with the Brussels griffon, pug and shih tzu. Early Pekingese in China more closely resembled the Japanese chin.
- Pug — shares common ancestry with the Brussels griffon, Pekingese and Shih tzu. Pugs originated in the Shang Dynasty of China in the 16th century; they did not have flat faces at that time. Over the next three centuries, the face gradually became shortened.
- Shih tzu — shares common ancestry with the Brussels griffon, Pekingese and pug. Originally a cross between the Pekingese and Lhasa apso. The Tibetan Dalai Lama gifted them to Chinese emperors near the end of the 17th century.
If you have a soft spot for pugs, Boston terriers, Shih tzus, or any other brachycephalic breed, don’t despair. Hopefully, as time goes on, recognition of their predisposition to respiratory and other health problems will become more widespread, and breeders will respond by gradually selecting out the features that cause these issues. In the meantime, if you are adopting a brachycephalic dog, whether he’s a purebred or mixed breed, be aware of his potential health problems and do what you can to prevent issues and give your companion a happy and comfortable life.