Thyroid dysfunction or thyroiditis is often misdiagnosed or missed altogether and it could be the cause for the sudden change in your dogs behavior.
When Robin Simpson adopted Tater, a 1½-year-old bull terrier, she knew she’d face a few challenges. On top of being deaf, Tater had already lived in three or four homes, and had developed behavioral problems. Much to Robin’s surprise, however, the first six months were a breeze. The young canine immediately settled in with her other dogs and cats, and his behavior needed only very minor correction.
Then the nightmare started. “During sleep, Tater would suddenly jump up, and make a sound I can only describe as a roar,” recalls Robin. “He would attack whatever was closest to him, whether myself or one of my other pets.” Once awake, Tater acted as if nothing had happened.
The episodes became more frequent until they occurred almost nightly. “Everyone I talked to said I should put him down, that he was dangerous and nothing could be done. But I couldn’t give up that easily on this animal.”
While Tater slept in a crate at night, Robin, a veterinary technician at the time, scoured the internet for clues about Sudden Onset Rage Syndrome. She learned that rages can actually be a form of seizure, and a search of an epilepsy site revealed more startling information — some seizures result from a thyroid condition. The site led her to California-based veterinarian and thyroid expert, Dr. Jean Dodds.
Dr. Dodds has been studying the connection between abnormal behavior and canine autoimmune thyroiditis for years. Her database contains some 2,000 cases and she regularly consults for vets and clinical laboratories. Dr. Dodds believes thyroiditis is often misdiagnosed or missed altogether. She wants to increase awareness of the early signs of the disease in both the veterinary community and among animal guardians, something she hopes will reduce unnecessary euthanasias.
“If these animals are not good companions, they’re going to end up being put to sleep, or in the pound, shuffled from pillar to post, and it’s not their fault,” says Dr. Dodds. “It’s a genetic defect, like all autoimmune diseases.”
What is thyroiditis and who gets it?
Known as Hashimoto’s Disease in humans, thyroiditis is basically an inflammation of the thyroid gland that runs in families. According to Dr. Dodds, if not treated, the condition almost always leads to clinically expressed hypothyroidism. In dogs, the symptoms of hypothyroidism include weight gain, poor skin and coat, and loss of energy.
Before this stage, however, the dog goes through a period Dr. Dodds refers to as the inflammatory “storm”, which can produce symptoms completely opposite to those of clinical hypothyroidism. “At the early stages of the disease, we’re seeing behavior problems such as biting, attention deficit disorder, moodiness, more separation anxiety or obsessive bonding with one family member. Or a dog that never barked at the mail carrier before suddenly can’t stand him anymore.”
Dr. Dodds’ research shows that some breeds are more genetically predisposed to the disease than others. Those with a relatively high prevalence include the English setter, golden retriever, Shetland sheepdog, American cocker spaniel, boxer, Doberman pinscher, Labrador retriever, German shepherd, akita, Irish setter, old English sheepdog, English pointer, German wirehaired pointer, Maltese, Kuvasz, Skye terrier, petit basset griffon vendeen, and the collie. However, all breeds, including mixed ones (particularly those made up of the breeds above), are affected to some extent.
What triggers the disease?
While genes determine which dogs may develop thyroiditis, like all autoimmune diseases it remains dormant until triggered. Triggers can be varied. “There’s an event,” explains Dr. Dodds, “either a chemical exposure, a stress, a hormonal change, another dog coming into the household or someone becoming ill. Vaccines are clearly an obvious trigger. They’re probably more associated with thyroiditis than some other chemicals because more animals are vaccinated than are exposed to substances like household insecticides.”
Because the symptoms of early stage thyroiditis mimic those of other conditions and behavioral issues, getting a correct diagnosis is not always easy. If a dog seizures, for example, your veterinarian will most likely put her on phenabarbitol, an anti-seizure medication. That’s why it’s crucial to get a full work-up, including a complete thyroid panel. Sometimes, in the “storm” stage of the disease, everything will look normal from the outside. “I had a case the other day in which the thyroid auto antibody levels, which should have been under 200, were more than 2000. The dog had attacked someone and the husband wanted to get rid of it but the wife pleaded with him to do this test. Sure enough, the results showed thyroiditis. But the animal looked normal physically.”
Once the blood test is done and sent to the lab, other factors come into play. “All labs have ranges for normal canine adults. These ranges may not be appropriate for the breed and age of your dog. The vet looks at the print-out from the lab, which flags low or high values, but the lab computer doesn’t know if this is a puppy or a senior or if there’s something breed specific going on. You have to look at it within the context of everything else. And many vets don’t yet understand this or know to ask.”
How can it be treated?
For cases that are not clear cut, Dr. Dodds recommends a six to eight-week trial of thyroid medication. Since the side effects of the drugs are minimal at best (panting, pacing) and it takes only 12 to 24 hours to completely exit the system after the last pill, it seems a safe alternative to a missed diagnosis.
For Robin, the veterinarian’s research proved a godsend. “Within a week of sending the bloodwork to Dr. Dodds, we had a diagnosis – autoimmune thyroiditis. Tater began a daily thyroid replacement and his rages were nearly gone after six weeks. He is happy and healthy.” Robin’s employer was so impressed with Tater’s recovery that the clinic began thyroid testing dogs that came in with abnormal seizure activity (motor seizures, episodes of staring into space or standing in a corner). Almost 100% of these dogs had abnormal thyroid function and improved on thyroid replacement therapy.
While she’s happy her experience is helping other dogs, Robin is most thankful for finding the key to Tater’s raging behavior. “Without a perfect diagnosis, my boy may not be with me today, making me smile and brightening up every moment. Now I know he will be with me for many wonderful years.”